Skip to content
Open 24/7 All of Maryland, from Baltimore
Maryland Chimney Sweeps logo Español (443) 659-7036

What Are the Downsides of Using a Gas Fireplace Insert?

The downsides of using a gas fireplace insert include installation cost, the need to match the appliance to your fireplace and venting, and less freedom to burn wood. We assess the existing fireplace and venting needs before recommending gas fireplace insert installation.

Need help now? (443) 659-7036

Which Downsides of Using a Gas Fireplace Insert Matter Most?

A gas insert can make an existing fireplace easier to use, but it is not a simple drop-in replacement. The unit has to fit the fireplace, connect to a suitable fuel supply, and vent according to its design. That means the installation can require more work than changing the look of a fireplace with gas logs.

You also give up the option of burning wood in that fireplace while the insert is installed. A gas insert depends on gas service, and some models use electricity for features such as a blower or ignition; check the specific model’s manual to learn what it needs. Those tradeoffs matter if you want wood fires, need the fireplace to work during an outage, or want to avoid installation work.

The right choice depends on how you use the fireplace and what the existing space can accommodate. For a closer look at the purchase and installation budget, see how much a gas fireplace insert costs.

How a Gas Insert Compares With Gas Logs and a Wood Fireplace

Gas fireplace insert

Choose this option when you want an enclosed gas appliance fitted into an existing fireplace. The main tradeoff is that the unit, fuel connection, and venting must all work with that fireplace; an installer needs to check compatibility before you select a model.

Gas logs

Gas logs can suit a fireplace setup designed for a burner and log set rather than an enclosed insert. They are not interchangeable with inserts, so ask which arrangement your fireplace and venting can support before buying equipment.

Wood-burning fireplace

Keep a wood-burning setup if burning wood is important to you. That choice retains the need to handle wood and ash and to maintain the fireplace and chimney for solid-fuel use.

Seven Checks to Make Before You Choose a Gas Insert

These are information-gathering steps, not installation instructions. Leave gas connections, vent changes, and appliance installation to a professional.

  1. Find the fireplace and appliance paperwork — Look for the existing fireplace’s model label, manual, or prior service records. Note the model and any stated restrictions so they can be compared with the proposed insert.
  2. Measure the fireplace opening — Use a tape measure to record the opening’s width and height, plus the depth you can reach safely. Check that you measured the actual usable space rather than decorative trim.
  3. Photograph the firebox and hearth — Use a phone camera to capture the inside, the front opening, and the area around the fireplace. Check that the photos show cracks, damaged masonry, or anything that might obstruct an assessment.
  4. Decide what you expect from the fireplace — Write down whether you value wood fires, convenient operation, or a particular look most. Check whether an insert’s fuel and operating needs fit how you intend to use the room.
  5. Identify the fuel and utilities nearby — Note what fuel service is available and whether the room has an electrical outlet near the fireplace. Do not open gas fittings or try to test a connection; ask the installer to check what the selected unit requires.
  6. Ask how the unit will vent — Ask which venting arrangement the model requires and how the existing chimney or fireplace will be assessed. Check that the proposed appliance’s instructions and the vent plan match.
  7. Confirm the inspection and installation scope — Ask what the assessment covers, what parts or preparation the installation includes, and what findings could change the work. Check that the scope addresses the appliance, its venting, and the condition of the existing fireplace.

Need help now? (443) 659-7036

What a Gas Fireplace Insert Assessment Should Check

An insert choice should follow an assessment of the existing fireplace, not just a measurement of the opening. The installer needs to match the appliance requirements to the conditions at your home.

What Happens During Gas Fireplace Insert Installation

The work starts with checking the existing fireplace and confirming that the insert and its venting plan suit the space. The installation scope can include preparing the fireplace, fitting the insert, and connecting the required fuel and vent components; the exact work depends on the appliance and what the assessment finds.

The visit length depends on the condition of the fireplace and the installation work required. Before work begins, confirm which tasks are included and what must be corrected before the appliance can be used. We provide gas fireplace insert installation service and come to your home.

To book, call Maryland Chimney Sweeps at (443) 659-7036 or use our contact page. Same-day service is available, and we are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Problems That Can Make an Insert the Wrong Fit

Do not treat an insert as a way to hide a fireplace or chimney problem. A proper assessment should identify conditions that could affect safe installation or operation before the appliance is selected.

Need help now? (443) 659-7036

What to Do Before Putting the Fireplace Back in Service

Use the appliance only as its manufacturer’s instructions direct, and keep the manual where you can find it. Check that you know how to operate the controls and which maintenance instructions apply to your specific model.

Stop using the fireplace and arrange a professional assessment if you notice damage, unusual operation, or a change in how the appliance vents. Do not remove panels or adjust gas or vent components to troubleshoot it yourself.

For a gas insert, the key decision is not just whether you prefer gas over wood. It is whether the specific unit, its venting, and your existing fireplace work together; our installation service can assess that fit.

Frequently asked questions

Can a gas fireplace insert go into any existing fireplace?

No. The fireplace’s usable dimensions, condition, and venting arrangement must match the specific insert’s requirements. Have the fireplace assessed before purchasing a unit.

Can I switch back to burning wood after installing a gas insert?

An installed gas insert is designed to operate as a gas appliance, not as an open wood-burning fireplace. Ask about removal and the condition of the original fireplace before treating a return to wood burning as an option.

Does a gas fireplace insert need a chimney inspection?

The existing chimney and the proposed appliance’s venting should be assessed as part of planning the installation. CSIA guidance identifies an appliance change as a reason for a Level 2 inspection, which includes a video scan.

What information should I have ready when booking an insert assessment?

Have the fireplace measurements, any model label or manual, and clear photos of the firebox and opening ready. Those details help the installer understand the existing setup before assessing the insert and its venting requirements.

Check the Fit Before You Choose

Call Maryland Chimney Sweeps at (443) 659-7036 to arrange a gas fireplace insert assessment.

More helpful guides

(443) 659-7036 Get a quote